- The Pragmatic Investor
- Posts
- šWhy Iām Not Buying Palantirās 9% Drop
šWhy Iām Not Buying Palantirās 9% Drop

šGood Monday Morning, Folks!
Palantir posted $462 million in net income and raised full-year guidance⦠and the stock still dropped 9%. Youād think they announced bankruptcy the way Wall Street reacted. But thatās the game now ā reality doesnāt matter as much as whatās already been priced in.
This isnāt just a tech wobble. Itās a surgical correction ā the market slicing hype off of high-multiple stocks and asking, āOkay, now show me itās real.ā And when even a company with 83% Rule of 40 metrics gets slapped, you know weāve entered a new phase: expectation fatigue.
In todayās deep dive, Iām cutting through the noise around Palantirās big drop ā not to say whether itās a buy or a bust, but to get clear on something most investors miss: how narratives detach from fundamentals, and how to spot when the marketās done pretending.
Because when conviction becomes consensus, and consensus gets lazy, the market punishes everyone still clinging to yesterdayās storyline. Letās talk about what really just happened ā and what matters next.
ā” Quick Hits
šŗ Inflationās Not Done ā Tariffs Are Quietly Re-Accelerating Prices
Just as markets start pricing in rate cuts, a new inflation driver is sneaking back in: tariffs. From appliances to auto parts, import costs are rising, and businesses are quietly passing it on. If youāre betting on a smooth disinflation glide into 2025, this is your wake-up call ā the Fed might not pivot as cleanly as the market wants.
š The S&P 500 Just Hit a Record ā And Could Still Rip Higher
Retail flows are back. Inflation is (kind of) cooling. And mega-cap tech is carrying the index like itās 2021 again. But hereās the twist: momentum funds are still underweight. Translation? This rally has room ā and if positioning flips, it could go parabolic. Stay sharp ā the herd hasnāt fully caught on yet.
ā ļø Teslaās āRobo Taxiā Buzz Just Hit a Wall
Wall Street just dunked cold water on Teslaās AI-driven optimism. A new downgrade from a top analyst slashes expectations for Full Self-Driving deployment and Robo Taxi monetization. Investors banking on āstory over earningsā just got a reality check ā and itās a signal that other hyped names may be next.
ā You Probably Donāt Need This⦠But If Youāre After 10% a Day, Read On
Most traders canāt even hit 10% in a year ā and Wall Street wants you to believe thatās just āhow it is.ā
But what if the real edge wasnāt in trading moreā¦
ā¦it was in trading smarter, with a system so precise, it can consistently target 10% a day?
Thatās the Ten% a Day (TAD) System.
š« No guessing.
š« No gambling.
š« No chasing momentum trades just to break even.
Hereās what youāll unlock inside:
ā
A proven daily framework for 10% compounding returns
ā
High-probability setups with built-in risk controls
ā
A minimalist, repeatable system that separates winners from wishful thinkers
If that sounds unrealistic ā great.
This system isnāt for traders who want to be average.
Itās for the 1% who want to break the rules ā and rewrite them.
š”One Big Idea: Palantirās 9% Friday SlideāIs This a Real WakeāUp Call, or Just Noise?

Last Friday, Palantir (PLTR) took a punchāa 9.4% drop to around $130. No messy earnings. No panic headlines. Just a market tapping out on expectation fatigue.
That hit? It wasnāt randomāit forced a question serious investors ask: Is the market finally demanding substance over hype?
Because hereās whatās frustrating: Palantirās a powerful story, but for years itās been selling on promise, not proof. And that gap is exactly where the market decided to get real.
š§© What Digging into Q1 2025 Actually Shows
From Palantirās own Q1 2025 Investor Presentation:
Revenue hit $884 million, up 39% YoYāabout $27 million ahead of Wall Street expectations.
U.S. revenue soared 55% YoY (total U.S. rev = $628 million)
GAAP operating margin was 20%, EPS came in at $0.08, and Q1 operating cash flow jumped 117% YoY.
TTM March 2025 revenue = $3.115āÆB, up 33.5% YoY. Operating income was $405.6M, net income (TTM FY24) around $462M .
Analyst view: revenue beat and guidance raise werenāt enough: PLTR stock fell ~7% in pre-market.
So yeah, the numbers are strong. But the market wanted stronger. And this drop is the marketās mic-drop: "Dreams are nice, facts matter more."
š„ Why This Moment Matters

Human truth: we all chase stories. We want to be ahead of the curve. But when a story becomes default, the real ROI is in hedged certaintyānot hype.
Palantirās been a hypergrowth poster-child: AI boom, Trump-linked government deals, retail retail fuel that FOMO. But Fridayās drop feels like a cozy corner turned coldābecause the narrative got way ahead of proof.
Read that as pain: all this optimism, and now a jolt of reality. Someone who bought at $70, $90, or even $120 is whispering: āWhat if Iām late?ā
šæ Growth, Profit, and the Marketās Scorecard
1. Growthāchecks in revenue, but not unchained
Official Q1 growth: +39% YoY
U.S. Commercial revenue likely seeing 70%+ YoY jumpsābased on $628M U.S. total and historical splits
Yet StockAnalysisās trailing number is 33%āsuggesting while Q1 had heat, full-year growth tempered
High double-digit growth excites the left brain; sustained growth keeps you awake at night.
2. Profitabilityāreal, but not blockbuster
GAAP operating margin = 20%; trailing net income ~$462M, operating income ~$405M .
Strong, yes. But growth + margin = rule of 40 enables efficiency at the expense of scale. Investors expect 30ā35% profit margins if youāre asking for AI growth multiples.
3. Cash & Dilution
Q1 cash flow surged 117% YoY .
But StockAnalysis still shows non-trivial R&D and stock-comp drag.
Bottom line: cash is growing slowly, not shackling dilution.
4. Valuationāwhere faith meets fear
Fridayās drop wasnāt at $80. It was at ~$129. Even after 9%, PLTR is trading at lofty earnings multiples.
12-month average target of $90.78āover 30% downside.
Forward P/E over 500x, far above peers like Salesforce, Snowflake, Datadog. Thatās a vault built on pure faith.
š„ The Pain Points Investors Face
Pressure to ābelieve bigā: ownership today is a narrative buy. But two quarters of this funding gap between promise and proof? That story gets tired.
Missed earnings pain: when youāre in a momentum rally, the pain of selling a dip isnāt just lossāitās the ego hit. I see you.
Sacrifice vs Hedging: owning PLTR feels like both owning a moonshot and praying you didnāt pay the full ticket.
But hereās the catch: emotion sells, conviction holdsāand conviction needs clarity.
š ļø What Iām WatchingāRaw Triggers Thatāll Tell Us If This Is Real
1. Q2 guidanceāare they front-loading optimism?
If Palantir again tees up a raise with vague descriptors, thatās textbook hype. I want cold, hard numbers.
2. U.S. Commercial surprises
Theyāve teased 70%+ growth. If Q2 doesnāt show sustained momentum, thatās a litmus test failure.
3. Margin leverage
20% op margin is solid. But can we get toward 25ā30%+ with scale and AI investment? Thatās where compounding gets real.
4. FCF expansion vs dilution restraint
Show me Q2 or Q3 with 20ā30% FCF margins and flat share count. Thatās maturity.
5. AI contracts outside defence & meme rally
Big government contracts get headlines. What matters is meaningful AI wins in healthcare, energy, financeāground-level customer adoption that sticks.
š„ Takeaways to Ponder
Fear of missing out? Thatās old. Now, be fear of losingāfocus on cash, clarity, consistency.
Greed? Only if Palantir builds a moat, not just hype.
Loss aversion? Recognize when the storyās done its workāand itās time to shift to fundamentals.
Curiosity: Q2ās next big moment. Watch the guidance carefully.
Pain avoidance: Investing without conviction is a ticket to stock insomnia.
š„ Final Take ā This Matters
I get itāsat on paper gains, missed rallies, hype cycles. But smart investing isnāt about feeling good after a rally. Itās about feeling right holding through the next reset.
Palantir isnāt cheap yet. Fridayās drop peeled back hype, but didnāt push it into bargain tier.
If Q2 delivers real growth, clear AI wins, better margins, and financial discipline, then it could break higher from a new foundation. If not, it may bounce in placeāor bleed into broader tech rotations.
This isnāt a buy-signal. Itās a progress report. If you own it, ask yourself: How hard do I believe theyāll execute on all fronts?
š§ Final Thought
One of the hardest things in investing is knowing when conviction becomes attachment. We start with a thesis, backed by numbers and logic, but somewhere along the way, the story becomes personal. Especially with companies like Palantirāwhere vision, mission, and charisma bleed into valuationāwe confuse belief with evidence.
But markets donāt reward belief. They reward execution. They reward margin discipline, product-market fit, and compounding efficiency. And they especially reward those who can separate whatās priced in from whatās proven. Thatās where clarity livesānot in the hype cycles, but in the space between performance and expectation.
So hereās what I remind myself in moments like this: You donāt need to predict the next 10x. You just need to avoid overpaying for someone elseās dream. Investing isnāt about picking winners. Itās about paying the right price for the right progressāand letting time do the rest.
š§ What did you think of today's newsletter? |
ā AK

Disclaimer: The content on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing in the stock market involves risks, including the loss of principal. The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not represent any company or organization. Readers should conduct their own research and due diligence before making any financial decisions. The author and publisher are not responsible for any losses or damages resulting from the use of this information.
Reply