🧨 Wall Street Punished Costco for Being Great, Not Perfect

🌞Good Monday Morning, Folks!

This market is drunk. Costco beats earnings, grows membership fees double digits, and Wall Street still dumps the stock like it missed payroll. You can’t make this stuff up.

And here’s the kicker — most investors will nod along with the sell-off. “Slowing comps? Must be trouble.” No. It’s not trouble. It’s gravity. And if you don’t know the difference, you’ll keep donating your edge to people who do.

This week wasn’t about numbers. It was about psychology. The market punished Costco not because it stumbled, but because it didn’t sprint fast enough to keep up with an impossible legend. That’s how narratives break — and that’s when opportunities are born.

I’ll break down why the crowd got Costco completely wrong, what I’m really watching in the quarters ahead, and how to frame dips like this without falling into the same trap. If you care about protecting your capital — and your sanity — you need to see this.

Because the real game in investing isn’t spotting perfection. It’s learning to hold steady when the market punishes discipline as if it were weakness. And Costco just gave us the perfect case study.

⚡ Quick Hits

📈 Buffett Indicator Flashes Red—Markets Are Overstretched
The Buffett Indicator, comparing total market cap to GDP, just spiked into “extreme overvaluation” territory. Most retail investors brush this off, but historically it’s a screaming signal that risk/reward is upside-down. Ignore it, and you risk being the last one holding inflated assets when sentiment snaps.

🤖 AI’s Big Three Still Driving The Rally—But At What Cost?
Nvidia, Microsoft, and Alphabet remain the backbone of AI euphoria, pulling markets higher. But here’s the catch: concentration risk is at historic highs—if any one stumbles, the whole narrative wobbles. The smart money isn’t asking “are they strong?” It’s asking, “what happens if perfection cracks?”

⚠️ Shutdown + Jobs Data = Volatility Cocktail
A potential government shutdown and critical September jobs data hit the tape this week, right as Q3 closes. That’s a one-two punch that could swing market sentiment hard, especially with valuations already stretched. If you’re not positioning for higher volatility now, you’ll be forced to react when it’s too late.

TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER

Run IRL ads as easily as PPC

AdQuick unlocks the benefits of Out Of Home (OOH) advertising in a way no one else has. Approaching the problem with eyes to performance, created for marketers with the engineering excellence you’ve come to expect for the internet.

Marketers agree OOH is one of the best ways for building brand awareness, reaching new customers, and reinforcing your brand message. It’s just been difficult to scale. But with AdQuick, you can plan, deploy and measure campaigns as easily as digital ads, making them a no-brainer to add to your team’s toolbox.

You can learn more at AdQuick.com

💡One Big Idea: Costco’s Dip Isn’t What You Think

Costco delivered. Profits beat. The market sold anyway.
And I’ll be blunt: when I saw the stock drop, I didn’t panic—I smiled.

Because this isn’t weakness. It’s expectation whiplash.
The crowd demanded perfection. Costco delivered “just” great.
That gap between reality and perception? That’s your edge.

Most investors looked at the red and thought: “Something’s broken.”
I saw a different story: “Here’s a chance to get ahead of the crowd.”

😨 Fear Is Expensive

You open your portfolio. Costco’s down $30. Your gut whispers: “Sell before it gets worse.” That’s not logic. That’s fear. And fear is the most expensive position you’ll ever hold.

Here’s the truth: Costco reported earnings of $5.87 a share on $86 billion in revenue. Both above expectations. Membership fees jumped double digits. E-commerce grew 13%. They’re adding warehouses like clockwork.

So why the sell-off? Same-store sales came in at 5.7%, just shy of Wall Street’s dreamier 6%. That single “shortfall” sparked billions in selling. Not because Costco stumbled—but because it didn’t sprint at superhuman speed.

This is what happens when a stock gets priced for perfection. At nearly 50× forward earnings, the market wanted fireworks. Instead, it got discipline. Investors punish discipline. But discipline is what builds fortunes.

🚨 The Costco Myth That’s Costing You

Every premium stock eventually becomes hostage to its own legend. Nvidia with AI. Microsoft with Azure. Now Costco with comps.

The myth? Costco must grow faster forever. Anything less = decline.

But comps slowing from 7% to 5% isn’t decline—it’s gravity. And gravity doesn’t kill a fortress.

The market didn’t sell fundamentals. It sold the story. And cracks in stories create openings for investors who can think past the noise.

📉 Panic vs. Reality: The Gap Is Your Edge

1. The “miss” is noise.
Headline comps looked weak. Adjusted for gas and FX, they were stronger. The market ignored the fine print.

2. Membership and e-commerce are thriving.
Membership fees rose 14%. E-commerce up 13%. These are sticky, high-margin engines.

3. Expansion runway is alive.
27 new warehouses last year. 35 more coming. Costco still has geographic white space.

4. The sell-off was sentiment, not fundamentals.
Costco was priced like a Ferrari. The quarter delivered like a Lexus. Investors freaked out. But a Lexus doesn’t turn into a lemon just because you paid Ferrari prices.

⚠️ The Landmines You Can’t Ignore

Let’s be clear: this isn’t risk-free.

• Inflation and FX can squeeze margins.

• Tariffs can sting sourcing.

• Renewal softness is a canary in the coal mine.

• Warehouse expansion can hit diminishing returns.

But here’s the nuance: cracks aren’t collapses. Mistaking one for the other is how investors torch capital.

🕰 History Doesn’t Lie

This isn’t Costco’s first rodeo.

• 2019: Comps slowed. Stock fell 8%. Six months later, up 25%.

• 2022: Inflation spooked renewal rates. Stock dropped 12%. One year later, up 40%.

• 2023: Headlines screamed “consumer slowdown.” Stock doubled in 18 months.

Every dip tied to “Costco fatigue” became a trampoline. Investors who sold early felt smart for a week—and stupid for years.

That’s loss aversion at work: avoiding a paper cut while bleeding out the upside.

🏪 Context vs. Peers

Line Costco up against Walmart, Target, BJ’s:

• Walmart trades ~25× earnings. Growth 3%. Margin pressure heavy.

• Target trades ~18×. Traffic issues still dogging comps.

• BJ’s trades ~21×. Smaller scale, less sticky memberships.

Costco deserves the premium multiple because its moat is structural. Membership fees are the tollbooth on America’s shopping habits. Whether you buy one item or a cartload, you pay. That’s not comps. That’s power.

🌍 The Macro Backdrop

Zoom out. Consumers are still spending, but shifting wallets toward essentials. Inflation is cooling. Rate cuts are coming.

Who wins when households tighten belts? Costco.

When times are tough, people cut Starbucks, not Costco runs. That’s why this company thrives through every cycle. The market just forgot that.

📊 Scenarios That Matter

Let’s frame it like I would if I were putting money to work:

• Bull Case ($1,050+): Comps stabilize near 6–7%. Renewals stay sticky. Expansion drives double-digit growth. Market re-rates Costco higher as a defensive + growth hybrid.

• Base Case ($950–$1,000): Comps hover around 5–6%. Margins stable. Stock grinds higher with earnings.

• Bear Case ($820–$850): Renewals weaken. Margins clipped by inflation. Expansion ROI fades. Multiple contracts.

The market is already leaning bearish. That’s the opening.

If this were my money, I’d call it a starter position zone—not a “bet the house” moment, but the kind of discomfort that builds conviction.

🔑 Why This Moment Matters

This week wasn’t about numbers—it was about psychology.

The market punished Costco for being mortal. And when safe-haven stocks stumble, the panic is twice as loud.

That’s how narratives drift. Costco shifts from “invincible” to “slowing.” And that drift is where investors get paid—by recognizing the gap between perception and reality.

Here’s the nightmare: you wait for Costco to “prove itself.” By then, the stock’s at $1,050. You avoided a 5% dip but missed 15% upside. That’s the hidden tax of hesitation.

🧠 Pragmatic Insight

Over the next two to three quarters, I’ll be tracking:

• Same-store sales—do they stabilize or reaccelerate?

• Renewal rates—do they stay above 90%?

• Margins—do they hold up against inflation?

• Warehouse productivity—are expansions still accretive?

If these stay intact, this sell-off will look laughable in hindsight.

Costco isn’t about chasing perfection. It’s about buying discipline when the crowd panics. That’s the edge.

✅ Takeaway

• The sell-off was perception, not fundamentals.

• Costco’s moat—membership, e-commerce, expansion—is alive and well.

• This dip isn’t danger. It’s discomfort. And discomfort is where conviction is built.

By next quarter, we’ll know if this was a stumble or the start of narrative drift. If comps tick back above 6% and renewals stay firm, the same investors who dumped Costco at $915 will be scrambling to buy it back $100 higher.

I’ll be watching. Will you?

TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER

CoreWeave gained 209%. We called it early.

Stocks & Income’s free daily investing newsletter sends you the breakout stocks before they go mainstream.

Here are some recent highlights:

✅ CoreWeave (before it soared 209%)
✅ Palantir (+441% this year)
✅ On Holding (+25%)
✅ Nova Ltd. (+13% so far)

And much, much more.

Read what we’re tracking next before it takes off.

With Stocks & Income, you’ll get AI stock picks, streamlined news coverage, key charts, and 1-sentence sector updates—all built to help you invest smarter and beat the market in 5 minutes per day.

It’s 100% free and delivered daily to your inbox.

Join 100,000+ smart investors receiving the breakout trades early.

Subscribe for Daily Stock Signals, AI Stock Picks & Market Updates →

_{Stocks & Income is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be used as investment advice. Do your own research.}

🧠 Final Thought

What unsettles investors isn’t usually the numbers — it’s the silence that follows them. A stock dips, the crowd scrambles for explanations, and the void gets filled with noise. I’ve learned to treat that silence differently: not as a warning, but as a pause. A pause that asks, “Do you actually trust your framework, or were you just renting conviction from the market’s mood?”

Moments like Costco’s dip remind me that edge rarely comes from having more data — it comes from holding steadier beliefs when others lose theirs. The real risk isn’t being wrong about comps or margins; it’s letting narrative whiplash dictate your decisions. Discipline isn’t glamorous, but it’s the only thing that compounds. And that’s the uncomfortable truth most investors never sit with long enough to see pay off.