• The Pragmatic Investor
  • Posts
  • Pragmatic Friday: 🧠 How I’m Positioning For Microsoft’s $600 Future

Pragmatic Friday: 🧠 How I’m Positioning For Microsoft’s $600 Future

In partnership with

🌞 Good Morning, Pragmatic Thinkers!

Microsoft was the AI golden child when it ripped toward the $540 region in late October.
If you bought anywhere near that top, you have probably stared at your brokerage screen and thought, “Did I just chase the last 10 percent and volunteer as exit liquidity?”

Since then, MSFT has dropped roughly 10 to 15 percent. It is not a crash, but it is enough to sting, enough to make you question whether this is the start of something ugly or just the market shaking out latecomers. The headlines do not help. One minute it is “AI will change everything,” the next it is “AI hype is over” and “megacap valuations are stretched.”

Here is the honest truth as I see it: this pullback is not Microsoft falling apart. It is the market finally pushing back on how much it is willing to pay upfront for AI dreams that still need to be proven in full financial terms.

In this Playbook, I want to do three things for you:

  1. Decode what changed after the October peak.

  2. Strip away the noise and focus on what is actually happening inside the business.

  3. Lay out a clear, practical roadmap for how I would handle MSFT from here, including a realistic path to 600 dollars.

By the end of this, you should know whether you are holding for the right reasons, adding with a plan, or just hoping the price comes back so you can “get out even.” Hope is not a strategy. Let’s deal with reality.

đŸ”„ Market Pulse – What Actually Mattered

đŸ’” Fed Cuts Rates Again in December 2025 — 3.50%–3.75% Range
The Federal Reserve backed by a 9–3 vote lowered its benchmark rate to 3.50%–3.75%, marking the third cut of the year. The move reflects growing worries over a softening labor market and lingering inflation, and sets U.S. borrowing costs to their lowest in nearly three years. Markets responded positively: major stock indices rallied, while rates on short-term Treasuries declined.

📈 When the Fed Holds Rates Steady — What It Means for Stocks
If the Fed pauses or holds interest rates steady, markets often interpret that as a sign of economic uncertainty — which can create a kind of “wait-and-see” mode among investors. Without a cut, borrowing stays relatively expensive and spending growth can stall; that tends to favor stable, dividend-paying companies or defensive sectors over high-growth or rate-sensitive stocks.

đŸ€– These 2 “Magnificent Seven” AI Stocks Are Offering Income-Yield Today
Two of the top AI-related tech giants — part of the “Magnificent Seven” cohort — are now presenting investors not only growth potential but also attractive dividend yields or buyback-backed returns, according to the analysis. For long-term investors looking to balance growth with yield, these names may offer a sweet spot: exposure to AI upside while generating passive income. This could be especially relevant in a low-rate environment post-Fed cuts.

TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER

Find customers on Roku this holiday season

Now through the end of the year is prime streaming time on Roku, with viewers spending 3.5 hours each day streaming content and shopping online. Roku Ads Manager simplifies campaign setup, lets you segment audiences, and provides real-time reporting. And, you can test creative variants and run shoppable ads to drive purchases directly on-screen.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

🎯 The Pragmatic Playbook: Microsoft’s Painful Pullback And The Real Road To $600

Let’s anchor where we are.

  • Microsoft pushed to a new all time high around $540 area in late October.

  • Since then, it has slid back into roughly the high $470s to low $480s.

  • That is a drawdown in the 10 to 15 percent range, inside a long term uptrend that is still very much intact.

On a long term chart, this looks like a normal pullback after a vertical move. On your account screen, it does not feel normal at all, especially if your cost basis sits closer to the top.

This is the tax you pay for arriving late to a strong trend. It feels unfair, but it is part of playing in mega caps after a monster run. If MSFT never had corrections, that would be the red flag.

The real question is not “Why did it drop 10 percent?” The real question is:

Is this a temporary reset in a long term compounder, or the start of a real unwind where earnings cannot keep up with the AI story that was priced in?

That is what we need to answer before we start pressing buy, sell, or hold.

đŸ’„ Why Microsoft Dropped After October

You will see easy explanations like “AI is slowing” or “Copilot is disappointing.” Most of that is lazy and surface level. The more honest version lives in four buckets.

Capex: AI Is Not Free

Microsoft is spending aggressively on data centers, GPUs, networking, and power to stay ahead in AI. Revenue is rising strongly, but the cost side is heavy right now.

  • Gross margins are under pressure because AI infrastructure is expensive up front.

  • Operating expenses are higher from AI related R and D and hiring.

  • Earnings are growing, but not as quickly as the market hoped when it slapped an “AI winner” multiple on the stock.

The market loves growth. It does not love when that growth arrives with temporary margin compression.

OpenAI: Great Partner, Ugly Accounting

Microsoft’s partnership with OpenAI is powerful strategically, but the accounting is messy. Losses and revaluations on that stake can hit reported net income and earnings per share even if the core business is fine.

On paper, that makes earnings prints look noisy and less clean. When a stock is priced for near perfection, messy reports are enough to trigger a shakeout. The story has not collapsed, but the optics have changed.

Valuation: From “No Brainer” To Debate Stock

At the October highs, Microsoft was being treated almost like a flawless AI monopoly. The market was pricing in years of strong double digit growth and robust margins with very few hiccups.

Once reality shows that AI capex is very real, margins wobble, and earnings get hit by one off items, investors naturally start asking, “Are we paying too much, too early, for this growth?”

That question alone can take a stock from everyone’s favorite to “maybe I should trim some.” You are watching a shift from blind faith to a more sober debate, not a sudden loss of quality.

Rotation: Taking Profits On The Winners

One more layer: flows.

  • After a long stretch where a handful of AI and megacap names drove a big chunk of index gains, profit taking is normal.

  • As interest rates move and the macro picture evolves, money rotates into sectors that look cheaper on paper.

  • Microsoft, as a multi trillion dollar name, becomes a source of funds when managers rebalance.

The result is simple. Even if the business stays strong, the stock can trade sideways or down while expectations cool and portfolios rebalance.

The stock did not fall because Microsoft suddenly became a bad business. It fell because expectations, valuation, capex reality, and accounting noise all collided at the same time.

🧬 What Is Really Happening Under The Hood

Now the important part: is the business still compounding, or is it stalling?

Strip away the AI headlines and you still see a machine:

  • Company revenue is growing at a healthy double digit pace.

  • Cloud, including Azure, is growing faster than the rest of the company, driven by AI and traditional workloads.

  • AI workloads are now a real driver of cloud demand, not just a press release talking point.

  • The installed base of Office, Windows, Teams, GitHub and enterprise customers gives Microsoft a distribution channel most companies can only dream about.

This is the key distinction.

Microsoft is not trying to sell shiny standalone AI apps. It is injecting AI into tools that companies already rely on every single day. Office, Teams, developer tools, security, business applications, all of it.

There are still real open questions:

  • How much extra revenue per user can Copilot and other AI add ons generate?

  • How quickly will enterprises move from pilots to full deployment across thousands of employees?

  • After this wave of heavy spending, how much of that extra revenue will drop to the bottom line?

But none of those questions imply a broken business. They describe a powerful franchise going through a capital intensive phase in order to reinforce its moat.

The direction of revenue, cloud adoption, and AI integration is still up and to the right.

The drawdown is the market saying, “Prove the economics. I am done paying any price for the story alone.”

🚧 The Path To $600: 3 Checkpoints Microsoft Must Clear

Talking about $600 only makes sense if you tie it to actual business checkpoints, not wishful thinking. At that price, Microsoft’s market cap would be significantly higher than today, so the company has to earn it.

Here is how I frame it.

Checkpoint 1: AI Revenue Becomes Boring And Predictable

Right now, AI is still a “story.” For $600 to be reasonable, AI needs to look boring in the best way possible.

That means:

  • Copilot and AI services show up as clear, recurring line items in the productivity and cloud segments.

  • Enterprises shift from testing to full roll out, not just a handful of pilot users.

  • Usage based AI workloads on Azure trend steadily higher, quarter after quarter, without relying on hype cycles.

When investors can plug AI revenue into a spreadsheet without guessing, the market can justify a premium on those earnings.

Checkpoint 2: Capex Intensity Peaks And Margins Turn The Corner

The current narrative is simple: Microsoft is spending heavily to build and power AI infrastructure, so margins feel the pressure.

For $600 to be sustainable, that narrative has to evolve into something like this:

  • Capex as a percentage of revenue has peaked and is stabilising.

  • Cloud and AI related gross margins stop sliding and start nudging higher as utilisation improves.

  • Management can credibly signal that the most extreme phase of the build out is behind them.

That does not need to happen next quarter. It does need to become visible on a 2 to 3 year horizon. When that inflection shows up, the market can move from “show me” back to “I will pay up for this growth.”

Checkpoint 3: Earnings And Buybacks Do Quiet Compounding

Microsoft generates serious free cash flow. A lot of it ends up back in shareholder hands through dividends and repurchases.

If:

  • Earnings keep compounding in the teens, and

  • The share count slowly trends down from consistent buybacks,

then earnings per share can rise faster than revenue alone. Combine that with a rational, not insane, valuation multiple, and you get a share price that can sit in the $600 region on a three to five year window.

$600 is not a three month trade. It is the outcome of AI becoming a visible, profitable engine, capex intensity easing, and earnings plus buybacks doing their job over time. If you want that outcome, you have to accept volatility on the way.

🧭 What You Actually Do With MSFT Now

Most investors get stuck here. They know the story is still good, but they hate the red. So they freeze, doom scroll, and hope.

Hope does not move your net worth in the right direction. A plan does.

Let’s break this into three situations.

1. You Bought Near The Highs

If your cost basis is somewhere around $500 to $540, here is the raw reality:

  • Yes, it hurts.

  • No, that alone does not mean you should dump it.

Ask yourself three simple questions:

  1. Has my thesis actually changed?
    If your thesis was “AI will fix everything instantly,” then it was never solid.
    If your thesis is “Microsoft is one of the core winners of AI and cloud over the next decade,” nothing structural has broken yet.

  2. Is my position size making me emotional?
    If you cannot sleep, or you are checking the price multiple times a day, your position is probably too big.
    Trimming 10 to 20 percent to get back to a size you can think clearly about is not weakness. It is risk management.

  3. Am I forced to sell?
    If you used leverage or margin, the market now controls you. That is the real danger zone.
    If you are fully funded with long term capital, you have options. Use them.

Practical move:
If the thesis is intact and the position is not oversized, my default is to hold, not panic sell. If the position is too large, I trim it down to a level that lets me think clearly and I let the business catch up to the price I paid.

2. You Are Still On The Sidelines

If you missed the run and are now watching the pullback thinking, “Is this finally my entry?”, structure it like this:

  • Decide on a total position size you are comfortable with.

  • Break it into three or four tranches.

  • Buy one tranche in the current zone, keep the rest for deeper dips or broader market corrections.

You are not trying to pick the exact bottom. You are trying to build a reasonable average cost in a high quality compounder.

Simple rule I like:
Never go all in on a single entry. Always leave room to either add lower or stay sane if the stock rips higher without you.

3. You Have A Large Portfolio And MSFT Is Huge

If Microsoft has grown into a giant part of your portfolio over the last few years, your real risk might be concentration, not direction.

Ask:

  • “If MSFT dropped 30 percent from here, would it blow up my long term plan?”

If the answer is yes, you have a portfolio construction issue.

Practical move:

  • Set a maximum single stock cap for your portfolio, for example 10 to 15 percent.

  • Use moments like this pullback as checkpoints to rebalance toward that cap.

  • Do not let one star position turn into a single point of failure for your future.

đŸ§± The Pragmatic MSFT Checklist

Here is how I keep my thinking clean on Microsoft.

If I can honestly answer “yes” to these, my default posture is to hold or accumulate rather than panic:

  • Is revenue still growing at a healthy clip?

  • Is cloud, especially Azure, still taking share and growing faster than the company overall?

  • Is AI monetisation progressing, even if the margins and accounting are messy for now?

  • Am I sized so that I can live through a 20 to 30 percent drawdown without losing sleep or doing something stupid?

If those stay “yes,” I do not let a 10 to 15 percent correction scare me out of a long term compounder.

Pragmatic investors do not worship tickers. We respect cash flows, moats, and our own risk limits. Microsoft still ticks those boxes for me, even after this pullback.

TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER

The Future of Shopping? AI + Actual Humans.

AI has changed how consumers shop, but people still drive decisions. Levanta’s research shows affiliate and creator content continues to influence conversions, plus it now shapes the product recommendations AI delivers. Affiliate marketing isn’t being replaced by AI, it’s being amplified.

🧠 What did you think of today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

🧘The Friday Reset

This week’s Playbook on Microsoft isn’t really about one ticker, it’s about how quickly our brains melt when a “sure thing” pulls back 10–15%. You get fatigue from the headlines, regret from buying late, and that quiet shame of wondering if you were the last one in. That’s the mental tax of markets: not just volatility in price, but volatility in conviction. If it feels like you’re behind, you’re not. You’re just early to the part where you’re forced to think like an adult investor instead of a hopeful spectator.

When I zoom out, my edge has never come from guessing the next move in a stock like MSFT, it has always come from preparing my process before the move happens. Position size, time horizon, and a short checklist of signals will always beat whatever the crowd is feeling this week. When the market slows down or chops around, real clarity actually speeds up, because you finally have room to separate story from setup. Hype doesn’t last. Setups do. If you can train yourself to come back to your process on Fridays instead of your PnL, you’re already playing a very different game from most people.

Stay Sharp,

— AK

Disclaimer: The content on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing in the stock market involves risks, including the loss of principal. The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not represent any company or organization. Readers should conduct their own research and due diligence before making any financial decisions. The author and publisher are not responsible for any losses or damages resulting from the use of this information.

Reply

or to participate.