- The Pragmatic Investor
- Posts
- š¤·āāļø Do I Buy, Sell, or Do Nothing?
š¤·āāļø Do I Buy, Sell, or Do Nothing?

šGood Monday Morning, Folks!
This market doesnāt reward indecision. It punishes it.
Every day I see investors stuckānot because they picked the wrong stock, but because they have no idea what to do next. Theyāre sitting on red, hoping it turns green. Sitting on green, afraid to sell. Watching the screen like itās going to whisper the answer if they stare long enough.
Hereās the uncomfortable truth: most of us arenāt making decisions. Weāre reacting to price movement and calling it strategy.
And thatās why todayās One Big Idea cuts deeper than usual. Iām breaking down the exact moment I stopped guessing and started managing my portfolio with conviction. When to buy. When to sell. When to do absolutely nothing.
If your brainās been bouncing between āhold foreverā and āget out now,ā this is for you. Let's get clear. Letās get calm. Letās cut the noise.
ā” Quick Hits
š Buffettās Buying Again ā Hereās Where It Gets Interesting
Buffett is doubling down on two companies while most retail investors are still playing defense. The Oracle of Omaha doesnāt swing often, but when he does, itās because valuations are too good to ignore. This move sends a strong signal: smart money is quietly leaning in while the crowd hesitates. If youāre still waiting for a green light, you might already be late.
šŗšø Trumpās āNew Economyā Pitch Isnāt What It Looks Like
The headlines are full of bold economic promises from Trump 2.0 ā but under the surface, itās a mix of populist sugar and long-term uncertainty. From tariff talk to tax plans, the policy noise is rising again, and investors chasing the rally without factoring in political risk are flying blind. Donāt mistake loud confidence for stable ground.
š§¹ Dalio's Exit Is A Quiet Wake-Up Call
Ray Dalio just exited entirely from Bridgewater Associatesāincluding board and ownershipācapping a decade-long transition. The founderās departure signals a structural shift: if even Bridgewater is evolving leadership and ownership, it's proof that succession and governance matter more than guru popularity. Itās a rare clear event: leaders change, processes endure.
TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER
Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?
ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.
Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.
Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.
š”One Big Idea: How I Decide When to Buy, Sell, or Do Nothing
We spend so much time obsessing over which stocks to buy that we forget the real pain point in investing:
What do I actually do now?
Do I buy more?
Do I sell?
Do I hold and wait?
Do I just stare at the screen and panic quietly?
Over the past decade, Iāve gone through every possible emotional rollercoaster with my portfolio. Iāve sold winners too early. Iāve held losers too long. Iāve bought stocks I didnāt understand. Iāve hesitated to buy the ones I did understand because they were āalready up 20%.ā
And over time, I realized the real problem wasnāt the stock.
It was not having a process.
So in this Mondayās edition, Iām breaking down the actual system I use to decide:
When to buy a stock
When to avoid buying
When to sell
When not to sell
When to average down
When to average up
This isnāt theoretical. This is what I personally do. This is whatās helped me stop overthinking and start managing my portfolio like a real investor.
Letās get into it.
ā When I Buy a Stock
Hereās how I know itās time to pull the trigger:
I understand how the company makes money. Not ākind ofā ā I get it. I can explain the business model in 1ā2 clear sentences.
Itās in a growing market. Thereās demand, tailwinds, and real customer need. I donāt chase companies in shrinking industries.
Thereās still a long growth runway. Iām not buying a stock thatās already fully matured and priced like itāll never slow down.
Thereās a moat. Something that gives it staying power: network effects, brand loyalty, unique IP, scale advantages, etc.
I believe in the leadership and how they allocate capital. If I wouldnāt want the CEO running a business I owned, Iām not investing in it.
Bottom line: I buy when I know what Iām getting into and I like what I see.
ā When I Avoid Buying
Hereās where most investors screw up:
They buy stocks because āeveryoneās talking about it.ā
The price has been going up, and theyāre afraid to miss out.
They watched a YouTube video hyping it up as the ānext big thing.ā
Theyāre trying to chase momentum without understanding the business.
If Iām only buying because the price is moving and I feel behind, I donāt buy.
Thatās how you end up holding a stock that drops 40% and youāre stuck wondering what the company even does.
And yes, Iāve made that mistake before.
ā When I Sell a Stock
Selling is hard. Youāve either made money and donāt want to give it back⦠or youāve lost money and donāt want to admit it.
Hereās when I sell with confidence:
The companyās fundamentals are starting to deteriorate. Sales are slowing, margins are compressing, customer growth is falling.
The business is facing serious disruption, and itās not adapting. Think Blockbuster vs. Netflix.
Thereās been a major negative change in leadership or strategy that breaks my original thesis.
Iāve found a higher conviction idea that I want to reallocate capital into.
In short: I sell when the reason I bought it no longer holds.
ā When I Donāt Sell a Stock
This is where most people panic and get it wrong.
I donāt sell a stock just because:
It āfeels high.ā Feelings arenāt facts.
I read a bearish post online or some pundit said to sell.
The price dipped but the business is still executing well.
Iām bored and looking for action.
Iāve had stocks drop 15ā20% in a week and done nothingābecause the business was still firing on all cylinders.
If my thesis is intact, I hold. I donāt micromanage the chart.
š When I Average Down
Averaging down can be smart. Or it can be a disaster. Hereās how I know when to do it:
The price has dropped, but nothing material has changed in the business.
In fact, the fundamentals are still strongāand now I can buy at a better valuation.
If I didnāt already own it, Iād still buy it today.
A good company on sale is a gift. But averaging down without conviction is just doubling your mistake.
If you wouldnāt buy it fresh today, donāt average down. Itās that simple.
š When I Average Up
This is where most investors hesitate. Stockās already upāso they wait for a dip that may never come.
I average up when:
The company just posted strong resultsārevenue growth, margin expansion, bullish guidance.
My original thesis is playing out better than expected.
The stock is still reasonably priced, even after the move.
A lot of my biggest winners came after I added to a position that was already up. Momentum with fundamentals behind it is one of the strongest edges in investing.
Donāt be scared of ābuying highā if the business keeps earning it.
š§ What This All Comes Down To
Most investors arenāt struggling because they picked the wrong stock.
Theyāre struggling because they donāt know what to do after they buy it.
They donāt have a plan. So they rely on emotion. And emotion is expensive.
Every decision I make now comes back to this question:
āIf I didnāt already own this stock, would I buy it today?ā
If the answer is yes, I holdāor maybe even add.
If the answer is no, I ask: āWhy not?ā
If itās just nerves or price action, I stay calm. If something has changed in the business, I take action.
š§ Takeaways (In Plain English)
Only buy stocks you understand. If you canāt explain what it does, donāt own it.
Donāt buy on hype. If everyone is already excited, youāre probably late.
Sell when the business breaksānot when the chart does.
Average down only when your thesis is still strong.
Average up when the company proves you right.
TOGETHER WITH OUR PARTNER
Used by Execs at Google and OpenAI
Join 400,000+ professionals who rely on The AI Report to work smarter with AI.
Delivered daily, it breaks down tools, prompts, and real use casesāso you can implement AI without wasting time.
If theyāre reading it, why arenāt you?
š§ Final Thought
You donāt need 100 indicators, 10 newsletters, or a crystal ball. You need a systemāa clear, simple, repeatable process that takes emotion out of your decisions and gives you a reason to act, or not act, with confidence. Because most of the damage in investing doesnāt come from bad companiesāit comes from unclear thinking. We donāt get wrecked because we picked the wrong stock. We get wrecked because we didnāt define what to do with it once we owned it.
At some point, every serious investor figures this out: your edge isnāt predictionāitās preparation. The difference between someone who panics in a drawdown and someone who calmly holds the line isnāt talent. Itās clarity. Theyāve already thought through what earns a buy, what deserves a sell, and whatās worth holding even when the marketās screaming otherwise.
So the next time youāre staring at a stock thinking, āBuy, Sell, or Do Nothingāāpause. Ask better questions. Because thatās how you go from confused trader to calm investor. Thatās where the real edge begins.
š§ What did you think of today's newsletter? |
ā AK

Disclaimer: The content on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing in the stock market involves risks, including the loss of principal. The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not represent any company or organization. Readers should conduct their own research and due diligence before making any financial decisions. The author and publisher are not responsible for any losses or damages resulting from the use of this information.
Reply